Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Three Va. universities land on top patents list

Three Virginia research universities have made the National Academy of Inventors’ new list ranking the nation’s universities that were granted the most patents in 2022.

The University of Virginia, Virginia Commonwealth University and George Mason University each made the list released Aug. 30, ranking 43rd, 86th and 91st respectively. U.Va. had 52 patents issued in 2022; VCU had 17 patents and GMU had 15.

The National Academy of Inventors announced the list Tuesday using calendar year data gathered by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. It is intended to “highlight and celebrate U.S. universities that play a large role in advancing innovation and invention in the United States” and follows NAI’s Top 100 Worldwide Universities list, which has been published since 2013.

“As a U.S.-based national academy, it is important to us not only to showcase innovation happening on the broader world stage, but here at home as well. Invention has been part of the American experience since the country’s inception, with intellectual property being protected in the Constitution,” NAI Executive Director Jamie Renee said in a statement. “Innovation has always been at the heart of U.S. culture, and the Top 100 U.S. Universities list allows us to recognize and celebrate the commitment these universities have to the American tradition of invention and protection of IP.”

The University of California topped the U.S. universities list as well as the worldwide list of institutions, ranking No. 1 in calendar year 2022 with 570 patents, followed by Massachusetts Institute of Technology with 343 patents, ranking second on both lists. In Virginia, only U.Va. made the 2022 worldwide list, ranking No. 65.

Richard Chylla, executive director of U.Va.’s Licensing and Ventures Group, told Virginia Business that most of the university’s patents are in the life sciences, mechanical engineering and biomedical engineering, including medical devices — all fields on which U.Va. focuses a majority of its research. Patents, he added, can take between two and five years from filing to issuance.

Patents provide incentives for companies to license patent rights, and that money is reinvested in university research enterprises; licensing fees generate between $4 million and $10 million for U.Va. annually, Chylla said.

“It’s part of filling the obligation to the public; it’s a public good,” Chylla said. “So we’re trying to take the money that is spent on research at the university, most of which comes from federal sources, and we’re trying to get it in the hands of the public.”

U.Va. filed for 240 patents in fiscal year 2022, according to U.Va’s Licensing and Venture Group 2022 annual report. Granted patents included a method and system for enhanced deep brain imaging visualization, methods and systems in the treatment of diabetes, and molecular genetic approaches to treating and diagnosing alcohol and drug dependence. U.Va. also struck 85 licensing deals with 45 industry partners, down from 92 in fiscal year 2021.

According to information shared with Virginia Business from its yet-to-be-published 2023 annual report, U.Va. received 46 patents during fiscal year 2023, which concluded June 30, in areas including medical imaging and treatments for melanoma and other cancers.

VCU, meanwhile, filed for 144 patents last year and was issued 20, three of which were issued in Japan and Europe, according to its 2022 annual report, which focuses on the July 1, 2021-June 30, 2022 fiscal year.  Patents included devices and methods for repairing tissue damage, as well as processes involved with the treatment of sickle cell disease and detecting fungus in the gut. The university generated $3.12 million in licensing revenue.

“Transformational research and innovation happens every day at VCU, and it is due to our collaborative and transdisciplinary approach that we are the recipients of this recognition from the NAI,” P. Srirama Rao, VCU’s vice president for research and innovation, said in a statement. “The impact of VCU’s novel innovations and rapidly growing research enterprise is felt locally, nationally and globally as it continues to work to address society’s most pressing grand challenges.”

VCU’s research is driven by the One VCU Research Strategic Priorities Plan, which was launched in fiscal 2022 and outlines four research priorities, including enriching the human experience, establishing a just and equitable society, optimizing health and supporting sustainable energy and environments. The university says it has already met goals of becoming a top 50 U.S. research university and receiving more than $400 million in sponsored research funding, which it aimed to meet by 2028.

For fiscal year 2021, VCU landed at No. 50 on the National Science Foundation’s ranking of expenditures on research and development by public universities. U.Va. ranked No. 30, followed by Virginia Tech at No. 38. George Mason ranked No. 77, and Old Dominion landed at No. 136.

George Mason did not respond to a request for additional information by press time.

The Tampa, Florida-based NAI was founded in 2010 and is a member organization comprising U.S. and international universities, government and nonprofit research institutes with more than 4,000 individual inventor members and fellows spanning more than 250 institutions.

Nanotech company to invest $2.9M in C-ville expansion

Laser Thermal, a nanotechnology company spun out of the University of Virginia, will spend $2.9 million and add 28 jobs at its manufacturing, research and development facility in Charlottesville, Gov. Glenn Youngkin announced Monday.

The company provides testing services to companies wanting to understand thermal properties at the device level, such as semiconductor companies seeking to learn more about the properties of materials used in its chips, explained  Laser Thermal’s CEO and co-founder, John Gaskins.

In October 2022, Laser Thermal began selling a tool it manufactures to measure heat flow in devices. The company also has two additional tools in development, one to measure thermal properties at nanoscales invisible to the naked eye, and the other to measure bulk properties of materials, Gaskins says.

“Laser Thermal’s decision to expand its research and development capacity in Charlottesville highlights the economic development generated from our world-class universities like the University of Virginia and the innovation and talent they produce,” Youngkin said in a statement. “The company’s success also showcases Virginia’s ongoing technology sector growth and we look forward to a continued partnership.”

Founded in 2021, Laser Thermal currently has 14 full-time employees, Gaskins said. The expansion adds an additional 5,200 square feet to the company’s existing 2,700 square feet in the city’s Ix Business Park.

“As a native Virginian, there was no other place I wanted to start a company due to proximity to major shipping hubs and international airports, the ability to maintain collaborative ties with the University of Virginia, and access to bright young talent from the first-class higher education network that exists here,” Gaskins said in a statement. “Many of our employees are originally from Virginia, or are happily transplanted, and love working at a high-tech company located in such a beautiful, friendly, and innovative state.”

The announcement comes less than a week after Youngkin, U.S. Sen. Mark Warner and university and industry officials gathered in Falls Church for the public launch of the Virginia Alliance for Semiconductor Technology. The launch included a private summit with the goal of bringing together academia and business to develop ideas for encouraging the semiconductor industry to grow in Virginia.

Gaskins said he sees his company as “another piece of the semiconductor ecosystem, providing thermal measurements to companies and universities that really haven’t been available on the commercial scale up to this point.” Gaskins said the company is currently working on an Air Force Small Business Innovation Research contract, with others in the pipeline.

The Virginia Economic Development Partnership worked with Charlottesville to secure the project for Virginia and will support Laser Thermal’s job creation through the Virginia Jobs Investment Program, which provides consulting and funding to companies adding jobs to support employee recruitment and training activities.

Building an ecosystem

Even though William & Mary is best known as a liberal arts “public Ivy,” it’s also a research university where professors are quietly producing innovative technology — and are less quietly trying to create an entrepreneurial network to support it.

Local capital isn’t as available in the Williamsburg area as it is around larger state research universities like the University of Virginia or Virginia Tech. “We don’t have much of a real startup ecosystem” in the region, acknowledges Jason McDevitt, director of W&M’s Technology Transfer Office.

But under the leadership of W&M  President Katherine Rowe, the second-oldest institution of higher learning in the nation has been developing and encouraging entrepreneurship among students, faculty and the community through the Alan B. Miller Entrepreneurship Center, part of the university’s Raymond A. Mason School of Business. In partnership, W&M’s Tech Transfer Office has also been actively supporting the development of an ecosystem to commercialize university research in areas ranging from health technology to environmental protection and artificial intelligence.

“It’s a grab bag of different things. We’re always trying to find something that is commercially viable,” says McDevitt, whose one-person office plays a key role in bringing university research to market.

 “I provide guidance and advice to students and faculty looking to develop their technologies, particularly university-owned technologies,” he says. That guidance “can range from technology development to business development to manufacturing to legal to anything else such that our technologies become useful to the public.”

That can include licensing patented and unpatented technologies “to big companies, small companies and startup companies,” McDevitt says. The university also helps form some spinoff companies based on licensing intellectual property created by students, faculty or staff. 

Much of the research work at W&M is hands-on, says Dennis Manos, CSX professor of physics and applied science, and the university’s vice provost for research.

“The research has a practical basis; it’s not just scratching an itch. Each day a new problem arises. Solving those problems is what researchers are all about,” Manos says. W&M faculty and students “work sometimes cheek by jowl with industry and government to solve problems of interest and importance in providing fundamentally useful things.”

W&M inventors are rewarded with 50% of the net revenues from licensing activities. That’s at the high end of the range that universities are required to offer, McDevitt says. W&M’s earnings are reinvested in supporting research at the university.

Dennis Manos, a physics professor and William & Mary’s vice provost for research, says the university’s researchers are hands-on problem solvers focused on practical applications. Photos by Mark Rhodes
Dennis Manos, a physics professor and William & Mary’s vice provost for research, says the university’s researchers are hands-on problem solvers focused on practical applications. Photos by Mark Rhodes

Most universities with significant research funding have some type of technology transfer office, all of which have the same general goals: to manage the university’s patent portfolio, to license technology and to promote commercialization of research products and processes.

Some universities have formal entrepreneurial seed funds to help spur spinoff companies, but W&M does not. However, McDevitt says that the university’s Tech Transfer Office does make some small grants from its licensing proceeds.

Valuable stock

One source for commercialized research tools at W&M is the Virginia Institute of Marine Science (VIMS), founded as the Virginia Fisheries Laboratory in 1940 through the efforts of the then-chair of the W&M biology department. It’s now among the largest marine research and education centers in the United States, with a front-row seat to the effects of sea-level rise.

The institute’s mission includes conducting research in coastal ocean and estuary science, educating students and providing advisory services to policymakers, industry and the public. William & Mary’s School of Marine Science is also based there.

VIMS’ research has helped revitalize Virginia’s oyster industry, which had suffered from overharvesting, pollution and disease, McDevitt says. “Our disease-resistant oyster bloodstock is widely licensed to hatcheries along the East Coast, particularly in the Chesapeake Bay.”

Oyster health is a major part of Jessica Moss Small’s job as director of VIMS’ Aquaculture Genetics and Breeding Technology Center (ABC), which was started with state funding in 1997 to address the oyster problem. A portion of VIMS’ funding continues to come from the state — in 2022, it received $27 million — and “our primary focus is breeding in Virginia environments,” Small says. However, the impact of the center’s oyster innovations stretches from Maine to North Carolina, where its oyster strains are sold commercially.

When royalties are paid by the hatcheries, “the payments are made to W&M’s Tech Transfer Office directly and then 80% of that income is paid to ABC, which helps fund the unfunded portion of our operations,” Small says.

Although Small started in the field of molecular biology, she came to VIMS
almost 20 years ago to complete her Ph.D. and became the aquaculture center’s director a year and a half ago.

“I really like the applied aspect” of the research, she says, and “the resources are tremendous. We have a brand-new facility,” the 22,000-square-foot Acuff Center for Aquaculture, which houses a shellfish research hatchery. “It’s state of the art. We’re becoming the hub of shellfish research.”

Health technology

W&M physicist Ran Yang led development of the Britescope, an AI-assisted laryngoscope that helps paramedics insert breathing tubes in patients’ tracheas with greater precision. Photos by Mark Rhodes
W&M physicist Ran Yang led development of the Britescope, an AI-assisted laryngoscope that helps paramedics insert breathing tubes in patients’ tracheas with greater precision. Photos by Mark Rhodes

Other commercialized research at William & Mary is directed at solving health problems by drawing on resources from a variety of departments, including computer science and physics.

One disease W&M researchers are tackling is Parkinson’s, a progressive disorder that affects the nervous system and has no cure. Nearly one million people in the U.S. and more than 10 million people worldwide have the disease, according to the Parkinson’s Foundation.

Gang Zhou, a W&M computer science professor and inventor known for his work on smart health, is leading an interdisciplinary research team that’s tackling a Parkinson’s symptom known as “freezing of gait,” a temporary inability to move while walking.

The condition “is so dangerous,” says Ph.D. candidate Ken Koltermann, a member of Zhou’s team. “The patient doesn’t know it’s going to happen. It increases the risk of falling.”

A computer science scholar, Koltermann started at W&M studying hardware security, but his interest shifted. “I was introduced to a former student who was setting up a project for Dr. Zhou,” he says. “I became interested because my grandmother had Parkinson’s. This project kind of hits home to me.”

W&M’s team is collaborating with Virginia Commonwealth University’s nursing and medical schools on the project.

“We are the computing side. VCU is the health side of things,” Koltermann says. Together, the researchers created wearable sensors to help users keep walking as normal and avoid falling.

The sensors are attached to a patient’s ankles and send data via Bluetooth technology to a smart phone, which “acts as the brain,” according to Koltermann. With that data the phone determines whether a freeze is occurring. If so, it sends tailored vibrations to ankles.

In an effort to bring the product to market, “we’ve applied for patents through William & Mary and have received at least one commerialization grant,” says Koltermann, who is waiting to hear about another grant.

Meanwhile, William & Mary is also celebrating the imminent commercial launch of Auxulin, a dietary supplement co-invented by McDevitt that’s used to reduce the duration and magnitude of hyperglycemia for people with diabetes.

The patent for the supplement is being licensed by W&M to a startup company, which will pay sales royalties to the university. Auxulin Pharmaceuticals’ founders are Dr. Gary Ritz, an Ohio-based podiatrist, and his son, W&M Mason School of Business alum Tommy Ritz, both of whom have Type 1 diabetes.

In W&M’s physics department, Ran Yang leads a team of students in the Engineering Physics and Applied Design program who have engineered a smart laryngoscope. Known as the Britescope, the device uses AI to help paramedics insert a breathing tube into a patient’s trachea with greater precision. Although the Britescope is not yet licensed for commercial use, it’s still drawing plenty of attention, including from Virginia Innovation Partnership Corp., which approved a grant for the device last fall through its Commonwealth Commercialization Fund.

Now, in addition to being a physics lecturer, Yang’s learning to become a businessperson, she says, which brings up a whole host of new questions to research: “What is the revenue model? Do I want to license it or start up and run a company? I’m working with business mentors to find a clear pathway.”

McDevitt is among those mentors. “Jason helps me to navigate looking for patents. When he sees opportunities, he brings them to me,” Yang says. “William & Mary is supportive of faculty innovation, especially if you can bring it to the real world.”  


 

AT A GLANCE

Founded

The second oldest university in the United States, William & Mary was established in 1693 under a royal charter signed by King William III and Queen Mary II of England, Ireland and Scotland. It became a public university in 1906.

Campus

Stretching across 1,200 acres in downtown Williamsburg, William & Mary’s campus includes the Martha Wren Briggs Amphitheatre, Lake Matoaka and College Woods. Its Wren Building, built in 1700, is the oldest U.S. university building still in use.

Enrollment (fall 2022)

Undergraduate: 6,797

Graduate: 2,251

Employees

The largest employer in Williamsburg, William & Mary employs 2,845 people.

Faculty

680 full-time and 165 part-time faculty

Students

Female: 58%

Male: 42%

Minority students: 32%

International students: 6%

Virginia residents: 60%

Tuition, fees, housing and financial aid (2022-23)

In-state tuition and fees: $23,970

Out-of-state tuition and fees: $47,196

Room and board: $13,534

Average financial aid awarded to full-time, in-state freshmen seeking assistance: $27,548
(2020-21)